Blog

Electronic signature vs digital signature: which you need

An electronic signature is any electronic way of showing you agree to a document, such as a typed name, a drawn mark or a click. A digital signature is a narrower, certificate-based kind of electronic signature that uses cryptography and a verified identity. For most contracts a simple electronic signature is enough, but some filings and tenders require the certificate-based kind, so check the receiving party's rule before you pick.

What each term means

People use both words as if they were the same. They are not, and the difference decides what you can sign with.

  • Electronic signature: the umbrella term. It covers a typed name, a drawn signature on a phone, a tick box, and also the certificate-based methods below.
  • Digital signature: a method, not a style of handwriting. A mathematical key tied to a certificate signs a fingerprint of the file. If anyone changes the file afterwards, the check fails.

So every digital signature is an electronic signature, but most electronic signatures are not digital signatures. The word "digital" says how the mark was made. It does not say how a law treats it.

What the law says, country by country

None of this is legal advice. Rules differ by country and by document, so check with a lawyer or the receiving authority.

India

The IT Act, 2000 defines "electronic signature" as authentication of an electronic record by the technique in its Second Schedule, and says it includes a digital signature. Section 3A adds reliability tests: the signature data links to the signatory only, the signatory controls it when signing, and changes to the signature or the signed record are detectable (IT Act 2000, sections 2(1)(ta) and 3A).

A Digital Signature Certificate (DSC) must come from a Certifying Authority licensed by the Controller of Certifying Authorities, which checks your identity and address first (CCA, eSign).

There is also Aadhaar eSign. The CCA describes it as an online service that authenticates the signer through e-KYC, with no physical token, and keeps the signing key for one use only (CCA on how eSign works).

United States

The ESIGN Act defines an electronic signature by intent: an electronic sound, symbol or process attached to or logically associated with a record, and adopted by a person with the intent to sign it (15 U.S. Code section 7006).

European Union

The eIDAS Regulation has three levels (simple, advanced and qualified), and a simple electronic signature is data attached to other data and used by the signatory to sign (Regulation (EU) 910/2014, EUR-Lex).

A qualified electronic signature needs a qualified certificate and a qualified signing device, and the Regulation gives it the same legal effect as a handwritten signature (eIDAS, Article 25 on legal effect).

England and Wales

The Law Commission states that an electronic signature can execute a document if the signer intends to authenticate it and any formalities are met (Law Commission, electronic execution of documents).

Side by side

Simple electronic signatureCertificate-based (DSC, eSign, qualified)
How it is madeTyped, drawn or clicked, plus records such as email and timeA key and certificate issued after an identity check
What it provesIntent to sign, and the trail around itIntent, plus a verified identity and a tamper check
When it is requiredMost private contracts, in the countries aboveWhere a rule or an authority says so, such as some filings and tenders
Cost and effortUsually free or cheap, done in minutesCertificate fee, identity checks, a token or an online verification step

Prices for certificates vary by provider, so ask the issuer. We give no figure here.

When you must use a certificate

In India, the Ministry of Corporate Affairs states that all filings by companies and LLPs under MCA21 must be made using a digital signature by the authorised person (MCA, Acquire DSC).

Other cases to check before you start:

  • Tax filings: some returns need a DSC and others allow other verification. Read the instructions for your form.
  • Tenders: many portals ask for a class of certificate in the notice. Read the tender document.
  • Banks and regulators: some accept only a named method.

Ask the receiving office in writing which method it accepts. Keep the reply.

Which method for which document

Use this list as a starting point, not a ruling.

Usually fine with a simple electronic signature

  • Freelance and service contracts between two private parties.
  • Non-disclosure agreements, in the countries covered above.
  • Offer letters and employment paperwork, where no special form applies.
  • Quotes, purchase orders and change orders.
  • Consent forms and routine internal approvals.

Check for a certificate-based signature first

  • Company, LLP and some tax filings in India.
  • Public tenders and government portals.
  • Documents that a counterparty or regulator says must carry a DSC, eSign or qualified signature.
  • Cross-border deals where the other side is in the EU and asks for a qualified signature.

Excluded from e-signature rules altogether

In India, the IT Act does not apply to documents in its First Schedule. These include negotiable instruments other than cheques, powers of attorney, trusts, wills, and contracts for the sale or conveyance of immovable property (IT Act 2000, First Schedule).

In the United States, ESIGN does not cover wills, codicils and testamentary trusts, adoption, divorce and other family law matters, and certain notices such as eviction or foreclosure notices for a primary residence (15 U.S. Code section 7003).

In England and Wales, a deed must be signed in the physical presence of a witness who attests the signature, even where both use an electronic signature (Law Commission on deeds and witnesses). Wills need separate advice.

A simple way to decide

  1. Name the country and the document type.
  2. Check whether the document is excluded. If yes, use paper or the formal route.
  3. Ask the receiving party or authority which method it accepts.
  4. If it names a DSC, eSign or qualified signature, buy that from a licensed provider.
  5. If it names nothing, a simple electronic signature with an audit trail is the usual route.
  6. Keep the signed file, the audit record and any written confirmation.

Where simple e-signing fits

For contracts that need only a simple signature, you can sign a PDF online without printing. DulySigned makes simple electronic signatures with a document seal and an audit certificate. It does not issue a DSC and it does not offer Aadhaar eSign, so it is the wrong tool for an MCA filing or a tender that demands one. If you want to see how other e-signature tools differ, read how DulySigned compares with another e-signature tool.

FAQ

Is a digital signature the same as an electronic signature?

No. A digital signature is one certificate-based kind of electronic signature. Every digital signature is electronic, but a typed name or a drawn mark is electronic and not digital.

Is a typed name a valid signature?

It can be, depending on the country and the document. In the United States the test is intent to sign, and in England and Wales the Law Commission says courts look at whether the signer meant to authenticate the document. Check with a lawyer for your case.

Do I need a DSC to sign a contract in India?

Not for most private contracts, but companies and LLPs need one for MCA filings. Ask the authority or your adviser which method applies to your document.

Can I use one signature type for every document?

No. Wills, property sale contracts, deeds and some filings follow their own rules. Confirm the rule for each document before you sign.

Sources

  1. The Information Technology Act, 2000 www.indiacode.nic.in, checked 2026-11-14
  2. eSign, CCA cca.gov.in, checked 2026-11-14
  3. 15 U.S. Code 7006: Definitions www.law.cornell.edu, checked 2026-11-14
  4. 15 U.S. Code 7003: Specific exceptions www.law.cornell.edu, checked 2026-11-14
  5. Regulation 910/2014 e-IDAS, EUR-Lex eur-lex.europa.eu, checked 2026-11-14
  6. Electronic execution of documents, Law Commission lawcom.gov.uk, checked 2026-11-14
  7. Acquire DSC, Ministry of Corporate Affairs www.mca.gov.in, checked 2026-11-14

Get your next document signed today.

Start free